I have had trouble getting retractable clips that work well. I was so happy with the silver one when I received it in the mail. It is heavy, attractive, easy to use. Yesterday the cable broke when my one year old son pulled on it. I think it should have held up a little better. I will order a new one, but am hoping it can last a little longer than 4 months this time!
I ordered the Silver ID Clip. The quality is very good, it has a strong clip on the back and the retractable cord is long enough to reach the lock on a door from my chest.
This product is nice and just the right size.